Edward Reid 0

Defiance, the Bielksi brothers, heroes or bandits? Does it make a difference when they serve a purpose in Hollywood?

Who were the Bielski's?  Were they courageous Jews fighting Nazi Germans or could it be something different?  Could they simply be necessary to create a narrative about heroic Jews in the midst of the Holocaust fighting back, regardless if they were war criminals? 

We can take a deeper look in this assessment. 

As an excuse for murdering innocent Polish women and children, here is what Robert Bielski, Tuvia Bielski's son, said 

"The Bielskis were not in Naliboki in May of '43," he said, echoing some politically correct historians who believe that the partisans did not arrive in the area until August of that year.

"But," he added, "even if it were true, which I know it's not, the 128 people are in no way close to the millions of people that the Polish people herded towards the Germans so they could be extinguished. I believe it's just consistent Polish antisemitism, and the Poles are sloughing off their own crimes of being an enemy of the Jews during World War II"

Sure, the Bielskis would continue crimes, like bilking a Polish Holocaust survivor? 

Aron Bell, the name Bielski chose when he moved to the US in 1951, the 80-year-old and his wife Henryka stand accused of a bizarre plot - kidnapping their neighbor, Janina Zaniewska, 93, putting her in a nursing home in a remote area of Poland and stealing her life savings of $300,000.

Not this time because he was caught, but for murdering innocent villagers, they were never held accountable. 

Do some Jews think they are above the law because they are Jews?  

I believe strongly in justice and that we should have standards applicable to everyone, but some people don't, and also, some historians are simply afraid of taking on cases like this. 

On May 8, 1943, a massacre of Poles that lived in the village of Nalibok took place. Partisan Soviet Bolsheviks committed this atrocity,  members of the so-called Bielski-Otriad, which formed a Jewish partisan unit operating in the Nalibocka Forest. As a result of this treacherous attack, 128 Polish civilians were killed in cold blood.

 

The Bielski's 

An excellent example of revisionism is using the Bielski gang and making them heroes. We see such a stretch to find courageous Jews in the midst of such horror they use these thugs; They could pick some other individuals, or are they just not finding any? They tried to create a film about Pilecki, but he had to be Jewish. 

It is factual that the criminal activity of the Jewish partisan gang under the command of Bielski brothers committed a series of murders and robberies on Poles. The investigation into this crime was halted.  They did this in cooperation with the Soviet partisans fighting against the members of the Polish resistance Home Army ( AK ).

This unit of Jewish bandits operating in an extremely ruthless manner became for the Jews an example of Jewish heroism. Several books were written depicting the Bielski partisans as rebels who fought the Germans. However, none of the books raises the issue of crimes committed against Poles, nor do they address what they did mainly throughout the war. That was robbing villages, not fighting Germans. 

A few years ago, in the movie 'Defiance' directed by Edward Zwick, the role of Tevye Bielski was portrayed by British actor Daniel Craig. Unfortunately, the movie was NOT based on reality, but on distortions, which once again hit hard at the memory of these tragic events of World War II because in the course of historical politics, the perpetrators are conveniently forgotten, and the war crimes are attributed to entirely innocent people, who were the victims!

 

The actual investigation into this by the IPN was on the lead but did not continue. Bielski's can simply say they were not there. Now any investigation into war crimes like this is considered antisemitic. Once again, above the law. There are different versions and the ones placing the Bielskis there were just halted because, well, you know, it was one of the other versions, so we should just quit. Really, perhaps it was the public outcry, like Jedwabne. 

Indeed though, who would not love a revenge movie about the Jews killing Nazis? Come on that is perfect Hollywood material and EVERYONE hates the Nazis! So find some Jews, although war criminals, and turn them into heroes, whatever works and whatever sells. Facts don't matter anymore when it comes down to historical films.  

The film "Defiance" presents an exaggeratedly idealized image (James Bond played the lead) of the Bielski's Unit, entirely skipping the issue of anti-Polish activities and minimizing the role of Polish culture in the Borderlands.

Searching for the origins of Naliboki war crime, one should go back to the negotiations between representatives of the communist guerrillas and the members of the Polish self-defense team, Eugeniusz Klimowicz, who was the self-defense leader in that area. He did not agree to join the Soviet troops, as it would lead to the structural liquidation of the Home Army in the Nowogródczyzna area.

The Soviet representatives promised then not to fight against the Poles. One should not rely on Bolshevik's assurances and promises the villagers were to learn on May 8, 1943.

That day, at 5 am, all hell broke loose. A series of machine-gun bullets flew towards the residential buildings. And then the slaughter of defenseless civilians began. All men, adults, and teenagers suspected of collaborating with the Home Army and Polish self-defense were led out of their houses first and executed.

Then the attackers murdered women and children and torched the church, school, post office, and residential buildings, looting valuables, food, livestock, and horse

Then they pompously reported to "effectively pitched the 'German' point of self-defense."  However, historians, when examining this issue, came to the conclusion that there was not one German person in the village.

Historical politics is sometimes used for vile purposes, and every distortion of history, regardless of the perpetrator's or the victim's nationality, should be thoroughly scrutinized and criticized if needed. But instead, it is being distorted to divert the attention away from some shameful historical facts in the hope of burying them and forgetting,

All victims of crimes and perpetrators should be remembered. If they find a Polish collaborator (which is hard to find - next time someone tells you Poles collaborated, ask them for twenty names? - We have lists and lists of Jewish collaborators within the Judenrat and  NKVD). That collaborator would be the representation of the Polish nation as a whole. 

This is not the only crime of Jews killing Poles.  My site discusses this.  As a non-Pole and a non-Jew witnessing the defamation and manipulation of Poland by many Jews, it is clear that before passing the blame, they should learn about what they did.  

I feel strongly that we are all humans and capable of evil, but many Jews, in particular, will not accept this and for decades have made the Polish their scapegoats.  That is unfair and unjust.  Anyone that believes in equality and justice should speak out as they did during segregation.  Racism is racism. 

No more moral double standards should be applied because by doing this, you are doing no better than propagating the Aryan ideology. 

 

Sources used – 

The Guardian 

Justice for Poland

 

 

Dodaj
komentarz

By dodać komentarz musisz być zalogowany. Zaloguj się.

Nie masz jeszcze konta? Zarejestruj się.

Ostatnio
dodane komentarze

Ten artykuł nie ma jeszcze komentarzy.

Categories

Login

edward-reid

Who am I? Get to know me closer

I am using this platform to continue the battle against revisionism and propaganda. Poland fought and suffered and are now being attacked in a variety of ways for various agendas.

In the name of historical accuracy and truth, we must respond.

More

Jews & Poles Database

Check the compendium of informations about Polish-Jews relations and encounters.

More

Latest
articles

Latest
comments

In a time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act

- George Orwell